Well if they didnt like the movie based upon a book because it looks too much like the book... then holy hell crap on a stick slap me silly thats stupid.
Besides, they complain too much, sure this movie has a little less magic in it, and more drama, but arent movies supposed to be just that... drama?
I mean, now all star wars movies were action packed, metal on metal, lightsabre battlefields. If it were it would bore quite quickly.
Wanna see an action movie? Go watch the new die hard... >_>